The X(itter) Renaissance That Really Isn’t a Thing

Every once and a while I see something bubble up on social media claiming there are masses of users flocking back to Xitter (what I call the site formerly know as Twitter, the x pronounced as ‘sh’). Well, actually what happens is that I occasionally get on Bluesky or Threads and see people making fun of the idea that there is some mass return to Xitter. So I decided to look into it and see if I am missing out on something.

First, looking around at Bluesky, it all seems the same. The people that were active there are still active. It is a robust space with a lot of discussion happening, even despite the fact that I have been lazy in following people back (sorry about that… still). From what I can see, Bluesky is not dying at all. I don’t really do other services enough to know if there is a difference or not, so I can’t comment about Threads, Mastodon, Signal, etc.

After a quick check to see if my Xitter account still works (somehow it does), and then closing out a mountain of scam notifications from the service itself (how many showers do people have to take after each visit? Yuck)… I look at my feed. Still deadsville. A few people that never left are still hanging on (I get it, you didn’t want to cede ground to the other side, wanted to stay and fight, etc. No judgement from me on that). No real new activity that I can see. Maybe a few people still doing POSSE finally figure out how to get their posts to go there as well? Is this the “flocking” I have heard of?

But the people still on Xitter seem to be convinced there is a flocking:

Saying the entire world got rich is… pretty out of touch with reality. And the attempted insult about only arguing about Ai and politics? Well, there was a HUGE political upheaval (blue tsunami) not long after this post, so maybe that wasn’t a waste of time?

The education people on Xitter are also buying into this return as well:

I’m not sure what counts as a “viable option,” but I can still pop into both Bluesky and Threads after being away for a long time and get into some great conversations on all kinds of topics. Seems there have been several viable options for a while. Or maybe things only count as “viable” if they are big and popular with lots of participants? That’s never really been my problem for sure.

But what about some kind of proof that people are flocking back? It seems to mostly be a bunch of “trust me bro, I saw hundreds” articles like this one by John Gruber. Gruber seems to really hate that people don’t like Ai but like to talk politics. His assessment of Bluesky is the opposite of mine, and probably says more about who he follows and what he posts than the actual state over there. He claims that “the culture on X today is remarkably friendly and inclusive” which… huh? I can spend 2 minutes verifying this is not true at all. He complains about Ai-haters jumping into replies on Bluesky, but seems fine with all of the White Supremacists still massively active on Xitter? Yikes. I’m still seeing them everywhere on my quick dip back over there.

Then he makes this head-scratching statement:

“If you returned from exile on a desert island and took a look at X today for the first time in a year, you might reasonably guess that Elon Musk got bored and sold it while you were away. I do think he got bored micromanaging it, but the rank muskiness that permeated the platform after he took over is — for now, at least — gone.”

I mean, I did just that (returned after being gone for a long while). I was immediately hit with Xitter trying to get my phone number, my bank details, trying to get me to choose from multiple paid tiers, and much more “muskiness.” Not to mention all of the hateful stuff still very much everywhere in the comments. Does he not realize all of this bears the distinct scent of Musk trying to get more money and control over everyone?

Speaking of head-scratchers: some ways of looking at this issue are kind of…. well…

Some of the people making commentary on social media don’t even understand how it works. “Ceded the floor?” That has really big “those tubes can be filled” energy. There is no one “floor” on social media. There are an infinite number of “floors” that go to who ever people want to give attention to at the moment. Someone could start an account tomorrow, post a thought that goes viral, and have thousands and thousands of people follow them overnight. There is no “floor” to “cede” on Xitter or anywhere else online. That is an old school outdated academic gatekeeper mindset.

If you are wondering where all of this weirdness about flocking back to Xitter came from, I think this article on The Verge by Gaby Del Valle pulls apart the argument nicely: The Midterms Proved Once And For All That X is Not Real Life. It probably also sheds light on why people on Xitter think that the current version of Ai still has a future in a world that is mostly rejecting it.

While Del Valle’s article correctly points out that “Most of the American public isn’t on X,” it also proposes some theories about what is happening to those that are still there:

“(JD) Vance, especially, is a creature of X…. White House aides, department employees, and Hill staffers are stewing in the same ecosystem. Writer John Ganz has termed this phenomenon ‘groyperfication,’ after followers of influencer Nick Fuentes, who call themselves groypers.”

The idea that the Xitter users quoted above and others are possibly subject to groyperfication is… not a good thing. So why are so many education people on Xitter so convinced that Ai is still a good thing, or that there is some kind of “flocking back” to Xitter is happening?

“The answer lies in the algorithmic nature of social media, X especially. If you interact with even one post about a relatively niche topic — say, genderbent Harry Potter fanfiction — the algorithm will feed you post after post after post about the same thing…. you may even delude yourself into thinking the issue clogging up your feed is something people just can’t stop talking about.”

To take this a step further: if you are only re-posting things about how people are flocking back to Xitter, or how Ai is going to revolutionize the world, that is what you are going to start seeing more of in your feed. Not to mention that Elon Musk is massively pro-Ai and Xitter, and is more than likely further skewing the algorithms behind the scene. If you only glance at criticisms of Ai and Xitter (or ignore them altogether), you won’t see much of them. Then you get things like this:

This is an example of how some people are not only discussing Ai as if it will eliminate the need for jobs (no actual real-world trend is going in that direction), but fantasizing about a reality where governments and business will still provide for us without jobs (not happening in any real country in any reality). How does discussing something that is not going to happen, under a government structure that does not exist, help with educational issues today?

One of the threads weaving through all of these quotes and examples is a hatred of politics and talking about politics. Which I get. But if you can’t see that education and technology are political now (even though, yes, they should never have been), then you are the one that has ceded any meaningful “floor.” Politicians have unfortunately drug education into politics. CEOs of big tech companies (and even worse, Ed-Tech companies) have embedded themselves in politics. The solutions for the problems that education faces are now political. Protecting “we the people” from the abusive side of business and tech has always been political. I’m just old enough to remember all of the people who got frustrated with “activists” that kept talking about car safety requirements and pollution limits and those kinds of things. It seems all of this talk about a Xitter Renaissance is just people wanting to avoid dealing with the consequences of the shiny things they wish were taking over the world.