Sal Khan is going to revolutionize Higher Ed. Again. I’m not really going to write about what the idea is here – some are referring to him as “Serial Failure Sal Khan,” so I doubt it will catch on.
People are (rightly so) connecting this “new” idea to past ideas that were supposedly going to revolutionize education: blogs, MOOCs, virtual worlds, learning analytics, Ai, and so on. Ed-Tech™ (as an industry) is littered with tools and designs that failed to revolutionize education.
And yes, I know that some will balk at the idea of constraining Ed-Tech™ to just the companies that sell specific technology to institutions. I get it. There is more to the field than companies. Ed-Tech™ companies don’t care that they are selling education tools anymore than the companies selling parking management technology or food service technology care about parking or food. When I go to visit friends that still work at universities, the systems and technology I use to park there, to eat a meal on campus, to check into their building, etc are occasionally or constantly changing. That technology is sold by companies that don’t really care to be called parking-tech or what ever. Some feel it is a stretch to put the “ed” in Ed-Tech™ – I get it. They are selling surveillance, or grade management, or tracking systems, or other things.
Most of my courses for over a decade were taught through open-source tools. I know there is open education, indie ed-tech, open-source tools, etc. One of my degrees is technically in “Educational Technology,” so I get that there is a lot more to educational technology that just Ed-Tech™ companies.
But those companies are so dominant that you can’t ignore their effect. Plus, you really don’t have “parking-tech thought leaders” out there telling everyone the newest phone app payment method is going to revolutionize the “parking by phone app” world. So that is why I use Ed-Tech™ – I’m not trying to include that local professor hacking and extending open source tools to deliver their course outside of the system. There are powerful, dominant companies out there trying to mold education into their version of “learning” through technology – which is more than a parking technology company trying to get institutions to upgrade to the latest version of their tech.
However, I also disagree with people referring to MOOCs, blogs, virtual worlds as “failed trends.” Those tools still exist to some degree today. Not to mention that they were created well before they became a trend, often by people that usually (although not always) scoffed at the later hype.
Technically speaking, these tools were not the failure. The thought leaders that hyped them were the failures.
For example, MOOCs are credited to George Siemens and Stephen Downes, neither of whom proclaimed these ideas were going to revolutionize education. It was (surprise surprise) Sal Khan that claimed there would be something like 10 universities serving MOOCs to millions of students each. The disconnect between original MOOCs and hype-trend MOOCs was so stark that people came up with terms for each. Remember xMOOCs and cMOOCS? Oh, and MOOCs are still around believe it or not. The actual failure was that of thought leaders that repeated Khans outrageous claims with a straight faces.
While it still might be too early to call Ai a “failed” trend – the numbers are still not good. Just from this week alone, the research is not promising. Workplace surveys are showing that only 13% of the work staff use Ai daily and only 28% use it weekly while at work. Those numbers are only up 1% and 2% from last year, respectively. While 2 in 3 say they are more productive with Ai, deeper dives show that on average employees waste nearly 8 hours (an entire work day) per week fixing Ai outputs (what some cheerfully refer to as “prompt engineering” as if it is a good thing). Just like other research has shown, Ai makes employees feel more productive when they actually are not.
The effectiveness of Ai in education is still not looking good, either. Research is starting to show that there is a “growing body of research suggesting that extensive AI use can distort and dampen users’ thinking and independence.” It also turns out that while there are hundreds of published articles that discuss Ai, very few are about good quality research. This review of K-12 literature, for example, found that “as of October 2025 the Ai Hub for Education Research Repository contained over 800 academic papers relevant to Ai in K-12 education” but “only a small subset (20 papers) produce strong causal evidence.” Those papers generally found that “Ai improves performance with access but when assessed independently without Ai support, effects are mixed” and that “Ai tools can alleviate students’ cognitive burden and foster positive experiences in learning, but can be at the expense of deeper thinking.”
So with the numbers not looking good, you have to wonder why so many are continuing to push the narrative that “Ai is inevitably going to revolution education”?
(And yes, it is a bit head scratching that some who were frustrated at their trend being declared the “future of education” have now jumped on the “Ai is the future of education” train.)
When you look at past hyped trends, there was always something else on the horizon (there was even a report about said horizon). When blogs were being touted as the future of education, there were things like Web3.0 (remember that?) and virtual worlds being developed. When virtual worlds were hot for a half minute, there were MOOCs coming up. After MOOCs, there was learning analytics. I think there was a blip of virtual reality? I probably blinked and missed it. After that was Ai. In fact, Ai was always in the background as something coming at some point.
But what is there after Ai?
I would contend that there really isn’t anything, and that is why the thought leaders and Ed-Tech™ companies are digging in so fiercely on something that is ‘meh’ at best, damaging at worst. Sure, some would say agentic Ai or autonomous robots or things like that are next – but all of those are technically just extensions of Ai. Without Ai becoming a major thing, those ideas don’t happen either. Ai is (in my best guess, at least) the last stand of the Ed-Tech™ grift, so they have to make it work.
Sure, there will be trends after this. And there will be “innovations” in the surveillance market as well. But what “new” technology – especially one that will “revolutionize” education – will they be able to pivot to after Ai fades? Ai has kind of been considered the pinnacle of computer technology for decades. So that is (to me at least) why you see the thought leaders and companies trying so hard to make it work. Even though it isn’t. We can only hope that the trend will truly die before we run out of water and resources to keep humans running in the aftermath.
Or maybe this is why we see Khan now coming up with an idea that apparently rolls together past trends like MOOCs, Google, and alternative certifications: the future trends in education will just be remixed past trends. Is Sal Khan the first in a line of people trying to be the bubble and squeak of education since he knows there is nothing after Ai? In some ways, that sounds worse than just getting another new hot trend to change the face of education. (With apologies to those that can make really amazing bubble and squeak.)
Matt is currently an Instructional Designer in the private sector and a Part-Time Instructor at the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley. Previously he worked as a Learning Innovation Researcher with the UT Arlington LINK Research Lab. His work focuses on learning theory, Heutagogy, and learner agency. Matt holds a Ph.D. in Learning Technologies from the University of North Texas, a Master of Education in Educational Technology from UT Brownsville, and a Bachelors of Science in Education from Baylor University. His research interests include instructional design, learning pathways, sociocultural theory, heutagogy, virtual reality, and open networked learning. He has a background in instructional design and teaching at both the secondary and university levels and has been an active blogger and conference presenter. He also enjoys networking and collaborative efforts involving faculty, students, administration, and anyone involved in the education process.