Obligatory Post on Xitter Alternatives Like Bluesky and Mastodon

With the rapidly accelerating decline of the once mighty Xitter (yes, the “X” is pronounced as “sh”), many people have been looking to alternatives. Many have also written some great guides about these alternatives. I’m not really even sure that I need to write one myself, as everyone reading this has probably already read a half dozen better guides. But I typed this out for some friends in a Facebook Group, so I wanted to save it on my own site before it got sucked into the MetaBlackHole.

First I have to admit I’m actually not on Signal, but I probably need to? I thought giving your phone number to a social media site was a bad thing… is it not anymore? I am also on Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, etc. I known they are also sometimes mentioned as Xitter alternatives, but they function differently. I’m going to stick with the three major Xitter alternatives:

Mastodon: Mastodon has been around the longest, and readers of this blog are probably the most familiar with it. People say it is more complicated and that is true. It is decentralized, so you will want to think of joining a server that others you follow are on. That is not a requirement, but it can be sluggish pulling posts from different servers than the one you are on. Longer post lengths also makes it feel blog-like compared to Xitter. Some like that, others think it feels like a slog. The fact that replies are not shown by default is apparently leading to a lot more targeted harassment in the comments according to some, so beware of that. Overall the interface is close(ish) to Xitter. Mastodon may very well come to be considered as something different than Xitter (mainly because it is).

Threads: Threads seems to work mostly like Xitter, but the layout is the most different. Since it is connected to Facebook, you get a lot of people that post the same on both, so it gets a little redundant if you are active on both. It also forces you to see a “For You” recommendation feed by default. You can switch to the feed of just those you follow, but it doesn’t stay. Threads feels more like a comment section of a blog than Xitter, but overall not bad. Just OK to me. Some people use it a lot, but it seems to be the second most popular alternative.

Bluesky: The guy from Xitter sold it to Elon and created Bluesky, so it is the one most like Xitter. A lot easier to to get started. There are even third party tools that will find your Xitter friends on there and even copy your tweets over. Since there are no forced algorithms, it takes some getting used to the differences in what you see in your feed. For instance, if you like seeing the replies that your friends make to accounts they follow but you don’t, you have to change a setting to show that (this view is the default on Xitter). There are guides to do all of this, plus there are some apps and add-ons to tweak your experience in different ways if you feel like geeking out. Bluesky also has “Starter Packs” to help you find lists of people to follow on various topics, but be aware that not all of these are legit and often have people that didn’t ask to be on the list, so make sure to investigate before blindly following or blocking all. Oh, and blocking works a lot better on Bluesky that other apps.

Bluesky seems to be the most popular alternative so far. It’s also where a lot of the critical Ed-Tech people went, so a good amount of the AI skepticism can be found there as well. Some have written about it becoming a progressive echo chamber, but that is mostly just centrist gate-keeping. Many different ideas are discussed and disagreed with on Bluesky every day.

For those that stayed on Xitter, no judgement here. I am still there as well, just much less active. Yes, Elmo is making it horrible. I also don’t blame anyone for leaving. For many, you needed to leave to protect yourself. But some decided to stay and fight, and that is not wrong, either. People have good reasons for doing both. A few people have even created accounts on all the new alternatives while keeping their Xitter account to cross post to all of them. Some have even chosen to use none of them – that is great as well. It has become a bit more like the Wild Wild West Web2.0 days in some ways.