How Dangerous is Ai for This Assignment?

One of the more misguided claims about the Ai Questioning side of the Ai debate (if it can be called that since one side so clearly trumps almost all other aspects of the conversation) is that we believe in sticking our heads in the sand when it comes to Ai. No one on the Questioning side has ever suggested that, so this is an obvious red herring response. In fact, the Questioning side wants people to understand the true state of Ai much more clearly than many do in order to understand the very real dangers it creates.

As much as I get tired of the “Ai is inevitable” discourse (because there are still many, many places where Ai is not part of anything), of course I recognize that it is here and that people will use it. Some people will even feel they have legitimate uses for it (even though I often disagree with them). Things like Ai usage charts can be a helpful tool in these instances.

One of the Ai usage charts that seems to be popular is from North Carolina, which first gained attention due to this EdWeek article last year. There have been updated versions since then. I had some concerns with the original one: using red for “No Ai usage” and assigning it 0 on the scale, while using green for “Full Ai Use with Human Oversight” and assigning it a 4 on the scale definitely gave the chart a major pro-Ai bias. The updated version removed some of the chart functionality that was helpful, added “Ai Resistant” to the 0 level, rebranded the highest level of 4 to “Empowered,” and added a rocket ship and an infinity symbol to the highest level. In other words, they doubled down on their pro-Ai bias. Plus, so many places you find any version of this chart has the table as an image, making it an accessibility nightmare.

So I decided to go back to the better first version, and re-frame it into an Ai harm chart. The colors were reversed, and a “Potential Ai Dangers” column was added.


How Dangerous is Ai for This Assignment?

Generative Ai Dangers and Disclosure Scale

Generative Ai refers to any of the thousands of Artificial intelligence tools in which the model generates new content (text, images, audio, video, code, etc.). This includes, but is not limited to, Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, Google Gemini, etc.; Image creators such as Dall-E3 and Adobe Firefly; and any tools with built in generative Ai capabilities such as Microsoft Copilot, Google Duet, Canva, etc., etc.)

Level of Ai Use Potential Ai Dangers Full Description Disclosure Requirements
0 No Ai Use No Ai generated bias or hate speech.

No made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

No water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers.

This assessment is completed entirely without Ai assistance.

Ai Must not be used at any point during the assessment.

This level ensured that student rely solely on their own knowledge, understanding, and skills.

No Ai disclosure required.

May require an academic honesty pledge that Ai was not used.

1 Ai-Assisted Idea Generation and Structuring Moderate to high chance of Ai generated bias or hate speech.

Moderate to high chance of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

Water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers depends on amount of personal usage.

No Ai content is allowed in the final submission.

Ai can be used in the assessment for brainstorming, creating structures, and generating ideas for improving work.

Ai disclosure statement must be included disclosing how Ai was used.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

2 Ai-Assisted Editing Low to moderate chance of Ai generated bias or hate speech.

Low to moderate chance of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

Water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers depends on amount of personal usage.

No new content can be created using Ai.

Ai can be used to make improvements to the clarity or quality of student created work to improve the final output.

Ai disclosure statement must be included disclosing how Ai was used.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

3 Ai for Specified Task Completion Chance of Ai generated bias or hate speech depends on usage levels.

Chance of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”) depends on usage levels.

Water or electricity consumption by Ai data centers depends on amount of personal usage.

Ai is used to complete certain elements of the task, as specified by the teacher.

This level requires critical engagement with Ai generated content and evaluating its output.

You are responsible for providing human oversight and evaluation of all Ai generated content.

All Ai created content must be cited using proper MLA or APA citation.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

4 Full Ai Use with Human Oversight Excessive opportunities for bias and hate speech.

High possibility of made up Ai responses (aka “hallucinations”).

Largest consumption levels of water and electricity by Ai data centers.

You may use Ai throughout your assessment to support your own work in any way you deem necessary.

Ai should be a ‘co-pilot’ to enhance human creativity.

You are responsible for providing human oversight and evaluation of all Ai generated content.

You must cite the use of Ai using proper MLA or APA citation.

Link(s) to Ai chat(s) must be submitted with final submission.

Adapted by Matt Crosslin from the adaption by Vera Cubero for the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction (NCDPI) from the work of Dr. Leon Furze, Dr. Mike Perkins, Dr. Jasper Roe FHEA, & Dr. Jason Mcvaugh. Link to Original Work.

Creative Commons Licensed BY (attribution) NC (Non Commercial) SA

Creative Commons Licensed BY (attribution) NC (Non Commercial) SA (Share Alike)
To remix this for your use case, you may make an editable copy, using this TEMPLATE LINK.
Please maintain CC licensing and all attributions in all duplications, references, or remixing.


Some might argue with the column order in this chart, but I feel the potential harms need to be front and center in any usage, partially because they are so glazed over (at best) in most usage discussion, but mainly because we really should be more upfront about the dangers that can cause real harm. I kept the necessary language and attributions in place, except for updating the link to the original work to the correct link. The template link leads to the most recent version of the original chart, which wouldn’t be helpful for updating this version. But it is there.

How Could AI “Just Disappear Someday” Anyways?

For me, one of the more informative ways to track a trend in education once it gets wider societal notice is by following people outside of education. As predicted, people are starting to complain about how low the quality of the the output from ChatGPT and other generative AI is. Students that use AI are seeing their grades consistently lower than peers that don’t (“AI gives you a solid C- if you just use it, maybe a B+ if you become a prompt master”). Snarky jokes about “remember when AI was a thing for 5 seconds” abound. These things are not absolute evidence, but usually tend to indicate that a lot of dissatisfaction exists under the surface – where the life or death of a trend is actually decided.

Of course, since this is education, AI will stick around and dominate conversations for a good 5 more years… at least. As much as many people like to complain about education (especially Higher Ed) being so many years behind the curve, those that rely on big grant funding to keep their work going actually depend on that reluctance to change. Its what keeps the lights on well after a trend has peaked.

As I looked at in a recent post, once a trend has peaked, there are generally three paths that said trend will possibly take as it descends. Technically, it is almost impossible to tell if a trend has peaked until after it clearly starts down one of those paths. Some trends get a little quiet like AI is now, and then just hit a new stride once a new aspect emerges from the lull. But many trends also decline after the exact lull that AI is in now. And – to me at least, I could be wrong – the signs seems to point to a descent (see the first paragraph above).

While it is very, very unlikely that AI will follow the path of Google Wave and just die a sudden weird death… I still say it is very slight possibility. To those that say it is impossible – I want to talk a minute about how it could possibly happen, even if still unlikely.

One of the problematic aspects of AI that is finally getting some attention (even though many of us have been pointing it out all along) is that most services like ChatGPT were illegally built on intellectual property without consent or compensation. Courts and legal experts seem to be taking a “well, whatever” attitude towards this (with a few obvious exceptions), usually based on a huge misunderstanding of what AI really is. Many techbros argue this misunderstanding as well – that AI actually is a form of “intelligence” and therefore should not be held to copyright standards that other software has to abide by when utilizing intellectual property.

AI is a computer program. It is not a form of intelligence. Techbros arguing that it is are just trying to save their own companies from lawsuits. When a human being reads Lord of the Rings, they may write a book that is very influenced by their reading, but there will still be major differences because human memory is not perfect. There are still limitations – although not precise – on when an influence becomes plagiarism. It is the imperfection of memory in most human brains that makes it possible to have influences considered “legal” under the law, as well as moral in most people’s eyes.

While AI relies on “memory” – its not a memory like humans have. It is precise and exact. When AI constructs a Lord of Rings style book, it has a perfect, exact representation of every single word of those books to make derivative copies from. Everything created by AI should be considered plagiarism because AI software has a perfect “memory.” There is nothing about AI that constitutes as an imperfect influence. And most people that actually program AI will tell you something similar.

Now that creative types are noticing their work being plagiarized in AI without their permission or compensation, lawsuits are starting. And so far the courts are often getting it wrong. This is where we have to wade into the murky waters of the difference between what is legal and what is moral. All AI built on intellectual property without permission or compensation is plagiarism. The law and courts will probably land on the side of techbros and make AI plagiarism legal. But that still won’t change the fact that almost all AI is immorally created. Take away from that what you will.

HOWEVER… there is still a slight possibility that the courts could side with content creators. Certainly if Disney gets wind that their stuff was used to “train” AI (“train” is another problematic term). IF courts decide that content owners are due either compensation or a say in how their intellectual property is used (which, again is the way it should be), then there are a few things that could happen.

Of course, the first possibility is that AI companies could be required to pay content owners. It is possible that some kind of Spotify screwage could happen, and content owners get a fraction of a penny every time something of theirs is used. I doubt people will be duped by that once again, so the amount of compensation could be significant. Multiply that by millions of content owners, and most AI companies would just fold overnight. All of their income would go mostly towards content owners. Those relying on grants and investments would see those gone fast – no one would want to invest in company that owes so much to so many people.

However, not everyone will want money for their stuff. They will want it pulled out. And there is also a very real possibility that techbros will somehow successfully argue about the destructive effect of royalties or whatever. So another option would be to go down the road of mandated permissions to use any content to “train” AI algorithms. While there is a lot of good open source content out there, and many people that will let companies use their content for “training”… most AI companies would be left with a fraction of the data they used to originally train their software. If any. I don’t see many companies being able to survive being forced to re-start from scratch with 1-2% of the original data that they originally had. Because to actually remove data from generative AI, you can’t just delete it going forward. You have to go back to nothing and completely remove the data you can’t use anymore and re-do the whole “training” from the beginning.

Again, I must emphasize that I think these scenarios are very unlikely. Courts will probably find a way to keep AI companies moving forward with little to no compensation for content owners. This will be the wrong decision morally, but most will just hang their hat on the fact that it is legal and not think twice about who is being abused. Just like they currently do with the sexism, racism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, etc that is known to exist within AI responses. I’m just pointing out how AI could feasibly disappear almost overnight, even if it is highly unlikely.