Is it Just Red? Human Creativity Versus Ai “Creativity”

I saw this meme shared by several people a last year and I meant to comment on it then, but totally forgot:

The meme is meant to be commentary on how Ai Haters just reject Ai art uncritically. I mean, the top painting is just red shapes, but the bottom one is actual art, right? Well, if you knew who the artist was on the top painting, you would realize how bad of a comparison this mean makes. I don’t know who made the meme, but they obviously don’t know much about art.

Full confession (that I have probably made many times already): I studied to be an art teacher at one time in History. I have to shake my head when anyone picks on modern abstract art (or whatever generic term people throw at this wide form of art) – even if it is a particular piece I don’t personally like. This attempt at critique started before Ai, of course – with people claiming things like “modern art looks like Kindergarteners made it!” decades before Ai was even invented. I try to challenge people to make modern art if they think it is so easy. The few people that take me up on the challenge quickly find out what I have also discovered: there is a lot more to it than throwing paint at a canvas, or painting a few straight lines. There is an intentionality to everything that is hard to recreate without a lot of time and thought.

The makers of this meme probably are confusing personal preference with imagination and creativity. I can easily see someone liking the Ai image on the bottom when compared to the top one. But I also doubt anyone really ever responds with something like “art requires imagination and creativity!” Art actually doesn’t require either. When people paint copies of famous paintings, they don’t have to use any imagination or creativity – but they still produce art. When someone paints a still life, they don’t have to use much imagination or creativity, but they still produce art. Artists generally object to Ai Cheerleaders claiming that Ai has imagination and creativity.

So let’s go back and dig into that top “just red” painting. It looks like it is probably Vir Heroicus Sublimis (1950-51) by Barnett Newman:

“This work’s title, which can be translated as ‘Man, heroic and sublime,’ refers to Newman’s essay ‘The Sublime is Now,’ in which he poses the question, ‘If we are living in a time without a legend that can be called sublime, how can we be creating sublime art?’”

As you can see, Newman is a theorist and philosopher. He put a lot of imagination, creativity, and thought into his artwork:

You may not like it still after reading and hearing all of this, but it is very obvious that Vir Heroicus Sublimis is not “just red.”

People also mistakenly thought that the red artwork in the meme was painted by Mark Rothko. I get why the mistake was made, but it is clearly Newman. However, Rothko’s paintings were also deceptively simple – they appeared to just be squares of one or two colors, but it turns out they were actually quite impossible to recreate. Rothko spent hours and hours layering his paint in ways that he often kept to himself, sometimes even mixing in non-paint materials (resin, eggs, glue, etc) to achieve various effects. Again, his work was not “just red.”

Artificial Intelligence is designed to be a pattern completion program. This process does not require creativity or imagination. In fact, if Ai were to utilize creativity or imagination, it would no longer be completing the pattern. Creativity and imagination would require a deviation from the pattern. It’s why we call it “thinking out side the box.” If you like Ai-generated art, then that is your choice. Just stop thinking you have some grand “gotcha” by comparing it to a random piece of “modern abstract” art. You might just end up making yourself look like you are very art illiterate. Which is a good way to invalidate your point about Ai-generated art in the first place.

Is AI Generated Art Really Coming for Your Job?

You might have noticed this Twitter thread about improvements in AI-generated art work. Well, if you are still on Twitter that is. Here is the thread – well, at least, until You-Know-Who “MySpaces” Twitter out of service:

So let’s take a look at this claim that AI-generated artwork is coming to disrupt people’s jobs in the very near future. First of all, yes it is really cool to be able to enter a prompt like that and get results like this. There is obviously a lot of improvement in the AI. It actually looks useful now. But saying “a less capable technology is developing faster than a stable dominant technology (human illustration)”…?

[tweet 1596581772644569090 hide_thread=’true’]

Whoa, now. Time for a reality check. AI art is just now somewhat catching up with where human art has been for hundreds of years. AI was programmed by people that had thousands of years of artistic development easily available in a textbook. So saying that it is “developing faster”? With humans being able to create photo-realistic drawings as well as illustrate any idea that comes to their mind – where is there left to “develop” in art?

That is like a new car company saying they are “developing new cars faster than the stable industry.” Or someone saying that they have blazed new technology in travel because they can cross the country faster in a car than a horse and wagon did in the past. The art field had to blaze trails for thousands of years to get where it is, and the AI versions are just basically cheating to play catch up (and it is still not there yet).

The big question is: can this technology come up with a unique, truly creative piece of artwork on its own? The answer is still “no.” And beating the Lovelace Test is not proof that the answer is “yes,” because the Lovelace test is not really a true test of creativity.

[tweet 1596680005638975489 hide_thread=’true’]

Yes, all artists stand on the shoulders of others, but there is still an element to creativity that involves blending those influences into something else that transcends being strictly derivative of existing styles. Every single example of AI artwork so far has been very derivative of specific styles of art, usually on purpose because you have to pick an existing artistic style just to get your images in the first place.

But even the example above of an “otter making pizza in Ancient Rome” is NOT a “novel, interesting way” by the standards that true artists use. I am guessing that Mollick is referring to the Lovelace 2.0 Test, which the creator of said test stated that “I didn’t want to conflate intelligence with skill: The average human can play Pictionary but can’t produce a Picasso.”

Of course, the average artist can’t produce an original painting on the level of Picasso either (unless they are just literally re-painting a Picasso, which many artists do to learn their craft). The people working on this particular AI Art Generator have basically advanced the skill of their AI to where it can pass the Lovelace 2.0 Test without really becoming truly creative. And honestly, “Draw me a picture of a man holding a penguin” is a sad measure of artistic creativity – no matter how complex you make that prompt as the test goes along.

But Mollick’s claims in this thread is just an example of people not understanding the field that they say is going to be disrupted. For example, marveling over correct lighting and composition? We have had illustration software that could do this correctly for decades.

[tweet 1596621251627335680 hide_thread=’true’]

Artists will tell you that in a real world situations, the time consuming part of creating illustrations is figuring out what the human that wants to art… actually wants. “The otter just looks wrong – make it look right!” is VERY common feedback. The client probably also created several specific details about the otter, plane, positions of things, etc that has to be present in any artwork they want. Then there are all of the things they had in their head that they didn’t write down. Pulling those details that out of clients is what professional artists are trained to do.

This is where AI in art, education, etc always falls apart: programmers always have to start with the assumption that people actually know what they want out of the AI generator in the first place. The clients that professionals work with rarely ever want something as simple as “otter on a plane using wifi.” The reality is that they rarely even have that specific or defined idea of what they want in the beginning. There is a difficult skill of learning to figure out what people actually want that the experts in AGI/strong AI/etc tell us is probably never going to be possible from AI.

So, is this a cool development that will become a fun tool for many of us to play around with in the future? Sure. Will people use this in their work? Possibly. Will it disrupt artists across the board? Unlikely. There might be a few places where really generic artwork is the norm and the people that were paid very little to crank them out will be paid very little to input prompts. Look, PhotoShop and asset libraries made creating company logos very, very easy a long time ago. But people still don’t want to take the 30 minutes it takes to put one together, because thinking through all the options is not their thing. You still have to think through those options to enter an AI prompt. And people just want to leave that part to the artists. The same thing was true about the printing press. Hundreds of years of innovation has taught us that the hard part of the creation of art is the human coming up with the ideas, not the tools that create the art.