Are You Asking the Wrong Questions of Ed Tech?

I wanted to take a moment to highlight a recent post by a colleague of mine, Dr. Chris Conway. Chris is a true EduPunk at heart that does a large amount of out-of-the-box thinking. He did a presentation recently at the Focus on Technology conference here at UTA. His session was called Asking the Wrong Questions of Instructional Technology. The blog post I linked to is a copy of his notes from the presentation.

One of the many things that sticks out to me about this presentation are the three principles that define innovative teaching: contact, collaboration, and creation. The last two will probably be familiar with most readers of this blog – in fact, you probably would have lost interest in this blog if you weren’t already in to online collaboration and having students create or actively construct their learning (if you aren’t familiar with the last two, go read those points right now. I’ll wait until you get back. Really – I will). The first principle is one that seems to get missed today in online learning. It’s not that we don’t believe in contact – we just that we sometimes get stuck in the rut of the same-old, same-old and don’t consider it very much.

Chris’ point about contact is that students should get to have meaningful contact with what they are studying – beyond just reading about it. The Internet is giving us as instructors or instructional designers a much greater opportunity to do this. You don’t have to just tell students about ground breaking research – you can actually send them to read the paper that was published to introduce the research. Or, you can even read the journals or blogs of the researchers themselves. Sometimes, of course, finding this kind of contact can take some extensive searching and digging. Or maybe even creating some opportunities ourselves. In other words, we may have to suggest to that researcher that they start a blog about how their research is going. If a good chance for making contact is not there – why not model collaboration as an instructor and see what you can get going? You would be surprised at how many people don’t do more online just because they just never thought of it, or don’t know how to get started (yep, that means you might have to set up a blog for a technically challenged person – but wouldn’t it be worth it? I can see you laughing mockingly at me – but you know its true).

So, if are not sure exactly what to tell people when they ask “what do I need to to do to create an online course?” – send them to this blog post for some ideas. Of course, if you are also like us and are stuck with a certain learning management system, you might not want to have them reading that last section where Chris talks about how we think the current LMS programs need to change. Let them discover that concept on their own :)

A Case For Asynchronous Learning

One of the things you might have noticed about EGJ is that we don’t cover video conferencing very much. The truth is – there really isn’t that much to cover. Most video conferencing news is about better quality video or better connections. Which is pretty cool – but there is just not much more to say about that. Not to mention that this is also news about expensive products that we can’t afford to buy. For me personally, there is also another reason I don’t cover video conferencing very much: I don’t believe they have much of a place in online learning.

Sure, for making a presentation or lecture from a distance, they can be great. To me, active learning is the way to go for learning in general, so presentations and lectures should take up as little class time as possible. Students should interact, in my opinion. Some feel that video conferencing tool is also excellent for interaction. I would disagree with that thought. I feel that asynchronous learning methods are better for online learning.

To me, one of the weaknesses of online synchronous meetings is time. Synchronous meetings always have an extremely limited time factor

A New Vision for Learning Managment Systems (part 1)

One of the reasons I feel that the EdTech community needs a new vision for the Learning Management System is because I’m not totally comfortable with the two dominant visions that I see out there. Much like in politics, so many seem to fall in to one of two extremes. One extreme is that the LMS is fine the way it is. Some like it this way because they like having a place to securely store a large amount of content. The other side is the one that wants to totally dump the LMS and go totally do-it-yourself. This is where the EduPunks seem to camp – the LMS is too constraining and limiting on their teaching. I suspect that most people are somewhere in the middle – just the same way they are in politics. But they just aren’t sure what that means.

I want to look at what that middle ground means – the position that is calling for change and progress, but doesn’t want to throw out the baby with the bathwater.

So, looking at the need for change, I want to look at why I used this image of a castle when I referred to “walled gardens” in my last post on this subject:

It’s not really much of a garden, huh? To me, walled garden is a good metaphor, but not totally accurate. For one, in most gardens, you can find your way around pretty easily. That’s not usually the case with learning management systems. As many have stated, LMS programs are more like boxes inside of boxes inside of boxes. Or, even worse – like a an old castle with a funny layout – including hidden passageways and trap doors. So that was one reason for choosing the castle image.

The other reason has to do with the walls. No matter how tall the walls around a garden are, you can still find a way to see over them because there is (usually) no roof. LMS programs are pretty closed systems from every angle, with only one way in – and that way can be removed at any time by the owner of the castle. Hopefully, now the usage of the above image makes more sense.

But let us also look at this thought of throwing out the baby with the bath water. Many people want to just dump the LMS and use Web2.0 tools to adminstrate everything. They usually quote their own experience as proof that the LMS is lost and in such a horrible state that it needs to be totally dumped. I want to take an honest look at this “in my experience” concept – something that I am just as guilty of doing. If you were able to look at even one school per day for five years – by visiting them, reading a new blog, making a phone call, etc – even on weekends, you are looking at 1820 schools. Even your most active full time conference speaker wouldn’t be able to accomplish that – so this is like the “gold standard” of experience. According to U.S. Census results, there are 129,404 schools and colleges in the U.S. So, even the “gold standard” of experience would only really interact with 1.4% of all schools in the U.S. in 5 years time – if they had no life! And this is just looking at schools – there are 6.8 million teachers in the U.S. alone. Each of them with a unique classroom situation of some sort.

Let’s also be honest about “birds of a feather flock together.” When we speak from our experience, we are probably mainly getting this experience from interacting with people that are like us. We tend to go to conferences that match our interests – so it would figure that of course we would run in to people that believe like us. I just say this to submit the idea that maybe our “experience” is extremely limited and possibly skewed a little bit. Maybe even a lot. Even those that travel a lot and read massive numbers of blogs.

We need to realize that our experience does speak to us that something needs to change – because if we want something different, someone else probably wants it, too. But we also need to realize our viewpoint is always limited – so don’t make it hard for those that the system is working for.

I think that this is a concept that those of us that like to look forward and innovate have a heard time swallowing: the system does work for some students the way it is. It just needs to be expanded and diversified to accommodate those that it doesn’t work for.

So what would that look like? Well, I laid that out in the last post on this subject, but I will expand on that further in the next post.

See other posts in this series

Formerly in this series:
Death of the Learning Management System? (part 5)
Death of the Learning Management System? (part 4)
Death of the Learning Management System? (part 3)
Death of the Learning Management System? (part 2)
Death of the Learning Management System? (part 1)

Just So You Know: Creepy Treehouses

We all see many trends, new web sites, and Buzzwords floating around the EduGeek-o-sphere. Most of them I just let pass because I don’t think they are going anywhere (of course, I might comment on something hoping to build buzz for something that I still don’t think will go anywhere but is still so cool that it really should…. but seeing that I haven’t been successful yet, I guess my big to rule the world is still falling short of my lofty goal). An example of something that I thought wouldn’t go anywhere and still hasn’t is the term “creepy treehouse.”

If you look up “creepy treehouse” at urbandictionary.com, you will see that it was added in April of this year and only has four ratings. Contrast that with a word like “driving finger“, added August 14th and already over 300 ratings. Are we really even dealing with a term that actually means anything to that many people? If you Google the term, you see the first several pages are mostly a handful of people all referencing each other’s blog posts, and not really a wide range of diverse sites examining the issues. Maybe it will still catch on – it’s still a relatively new term. Older than EduPunk, it seems – which is much more popular.

I’ve been arguing for a while that we don’t need to integrate LMS programs with existing social networking sites. Yes, it does invade student’s social networks that they probably want to keep separate. But I think that we need to make sure that it’s not the teacher using the tool that is the problem, it’s the concept of forcing their way in to social circles that could possibly make students uncomfortable (let’s also be realistic in noting that no one actually quotes any real scientific studies to see what students really think about this practice). If you are an instructor and you want to have a Facebook group or a Twitter account or whatever – go head and do that. Just realize that these are social circles and you shouldn’t force students to let you in their social circles. A FaceBook page is a new circle that you are creating – but also realize that it is a closed circle that pretty much mimcs everything that most LMS tools do.

It’s weird how we have the Marc Prenskys of the world telling us how stupid we are for not using these tools, and then this group of people telling us how creepy we are if we do use them. Can someone please do some research here?

If There’s a New Way, I’ll Be The First In Line

“If there’s a new way, I’ll be the first in line. But it better work this time.”

– Dave Mustaine: Peace Sells, But Who’s Buying?

Many educators are calling for a new type of education. One that is more fluid, open, self-guided. The argument is that humans are social creatures that naturally want to learn. So just set them free and they will learn like crazy.

Some go so far as to come up with titles like EduPunk and Anti-Teacher. They want to do away with everything from Learning Management Systems to semester-based systems to Universities all together. They are doing some great thinking, blogging, and boundary-expanding.

But can I just say one thing: Whoah! Baby and bathwater anyone?

It seems like to me that most of these people are those that grew up in a really traditional school that really quashed all questions and free-thinking (or, at least, they came to work in one at some time). Think Dead Poet’s Society for an example. So I can understand where they are coming from.

Of course, those of us that actually came from this open, fluid, self-directed education will usually tell you “ummm…. sorry… it doesn’t quite work either. Close – but still needs some work”

I was a “Gifted & Talented” kid – I’m not sure what it is now called. I was even in a GT class in High School – right after Algebra, English II, and Biology II. The goal of that was to give the really motivated learners the freedom to create their own learning in an environment that was free of traditional learning constraints. They tried two six-week sessions of experimental learning that usually descended in to us just goofing off and chatting. Then it was decided that they were still putting too many “conditions” and “guidelines” on us and that we should create our own curriculum for a six week period. All kinds of interesting ideas were placed before us – but then one student said “hey – can we watch movies for the whole six weeks?” That idea won the classes vote by 100%. The teacher decided to step in and say that we at least had to come up with educationally-based movies. So we did – it is surprising how educational “The Abyss”, “Lion King” and “Silence of the Lambs” can become when you put your teen-age mind to it :)

After that, they redesigned it and it became a great class. Oh yeah – we learned many things from those movies. Stuff I never used for the rest of my life except to maybe win a pink pie piece in Trivial Pursuit.

I am not linking to any posts or blogs about this issue because I don’t necessarily disagree with any one of these people. They have great ideas and some great thinking. I also think they need to realize that much of this has already been tried before to some degree – so don’t repeat the mistakes that have been made in the past (Montessori schools, anyone?). Also, please don’t make the mistake that just because things are bad in your (relatively little no matter who you are) corner of the world, that they are the same everywhere else. They aren’t.

To me, the best way to learn is still guided social constructivism, where learning is constructed for others while guided by a teacher or expert that keeps you on track while allowing you to learn. The important part is that the learner constructs knowledge for others. Self-paced learning is too self-focused and studies have proven that people will lose interest in anything if they just keep doing it for themselves. You have to have a grand picture of why you are doing something or you lose focus. “Without vision, the people will perish” is as true now as it was when that proverb was first written. If we are not careful, we will just have a repeat of the self-focused, self-loathing grunge movement hitting us again. Am I seriously the only person that has noticed the rise of grunge music coinciding with the first wave of self-guided learning?

EDIT: Please carefully read this post before posting knee-jerk comments. I don’t say GT, Montessori, or any of the ideas that I examine here or the people that believe them are bad or wrong. Read carefully, please. And, if you don’t know this already, the Montessori movement itself has been very open about the mistakes they have made through the years. I’m referring to the mistakes that they say they have made, not the whole movement itself (although there are many that would dismiss the whole movement).

Learning to Change, Changing to Learn

(Found at Ramblings of a Technology Coordinator)

3 C’s of Social Networking in Education: Context

To conclude my series on the three C’s of social networking in education, I will now attempt to examine a rather ambiguous concept: context.

Context is pretty ambiguous because I can’t really give you a range of steps on how to determine what the context is in your particular educational situation. Your context is your context, and it is different from my context or anyone’s for that matter. But those differences are important and crucial in determining which social networking tool you use and how you use it.

For you theoretical types out there who think I have missed the big “P” word, I hate to break it to you: I am using the term “context” in place of the term “pedagogy.” I’ve noticed that recently I’ve been growing tired of the word pedagogy, even though for a while I couldn’t tell you exactly why. Then George Siemens published a blog entry called “Pedagogy First? Whatever” that pretty much helped me realize what my problem was. I can pretty much sum up my feeling with one quote from Mr. Siemens: “if you want to create your very own pedagogy, you can likely find research that supports it.” I can create a sound pedagogy for flogging students with a rusty slinky if I tried hard enough. So just asking if a certain social networking tool is pedagogically sound will really mean nothing.

What you really need to ask yourself is: “will this tool be the right option for the context of my class and the outcomes that I desire for this activity?” Hopefully Mr. Siemens is not as uptight about the AP is with quoting, but here is some more meat from his excellent post:

“Few Utopian situations exist where our decisions on how to teach can be based exclusively on pedagogy. Resources, expertise, technology, needs (of learners, educators, society), and funds impact what we choose to do. In a world: context. The mix of multiple, mutually influencing factors determine what we types of technology we select.”

Determining your particular context maybe easy in some cases and difficult in others. See this page on Evaluating Context for some helpful guidelines.

3 C’s of Social Networking in Education: Community

To continue my series on the three C’s of social networking in education, I will turn my attention next to the one that seems to get overlooked the most: community.

The web has long been dominated by a “Field of Dreams” mentality: if you build it, they will come. Now that we have the ability to publish our own sites, blogs, videos, micro-blogs, etc – we tend to follow that line of thinking. If I put up a blog or FaceBook group or even create my own social networking site, people will just start showing up and using it.

But then a scary thing happens – few people show up and fewer even do anything when there.

Creating your own corner in some social network is just the very first step. People won’t come unless you get out there and invite them. In education, this usually is not that much of a problem because most educators will tell students and colleagues where to go. But regardless of whether you have a captive audience already or are just opening up a general site for anyone to come along, you have to spend time getting the word out. This is just the first step in building a community.

The next step is probably the most important one. Building a community takes consistent action and activity. You have to consistently give people something to socialize about. This is where I see many educational social networking activities fail. People set up a new blog or FaceBook group or other tool and then use it as if they are still stuck in Web 1.0. To use a few buzzwords, they use a “red/write” solution to publish “read-only” content. They don’t ask questions, start discussions, or even put anything worth commenting on. This is what many blogs tend to do – some even intentionally shut off the comments feature. Even some micro-blogs are not worth checking more than once a week at the most.

So, when you are thinking about setting up some social networking site or group, think about what people who come to your network will actually do or discuss. Give them something to socialize about. Give them a reason to network with others. Don’t just use it to show off your own witty statements or thoughts. Make it an actual activity to join in, not just another site to read. Thousands of new blogs and sites are started every week online – so give your small niche of visitors some reason to stick around. Think of a reason for them to socialize and build a community.

This can even be a problem in educational settings where students are required to visit. If you don’t do something interesting and educationally valid with the network, students will be tempted to just contribute the bare minimum and hit the road to a more interesting site or network.

3 C’s of Social Networking in Education: Consistency

I thought I would start my look at the three C’s of social networking in education by tackling the hardest one: consistency. I know I made that sound like I had a choice on which one of the three to start with. And the truth is, I did – I don’t think these three C’s go in any order. We really need to consider them all at once, and also work on them as they come up. You can look at the context first, or community first… but you need to look at all of them before jumping in.

So, consistency. You need to think of your social network as a television show. If you watch a television show that starts out on Monday nights, then goes off the air for a few weeks, and then comes back on Saturday afternoons, and then goes away for a while, and then comes back once on a Friday morning – you would give up watching it after a while. The same is true with any social networking site – be it a blog, or a podcast, or a wiki even. You need to look at your site visitors as an audience – if you aren’t consistently giving them new content to read or look at, they will check out after a while.

This gets hard for the working professional that is attempting to social network as part of their job. The modern mindset is that when the deadline is on, then that is ALL you can focus on and nothing else. Even five minutes spent off task and you will miss the deadline.

We know this isn’t true – but that is how we work sometimes. And I think we are seeing subtle changes in the younger generations – they value networking as much as the older generations do, but they are more willing so carve out a few minutes each day to do it.

So, that is what you have to commit to if you want to get some type of social network going – you have to make the time for it, even of the deadline is looming. The amount of time you commit would be in proportion to the size of your networking tool and also the expected update frequency. Micro-blogs and FaceBook take less time to update, but need to be attended to daily or every other day or else people will start to lose interest. So set aside 10 minutes a day to update those. Blogs and wikis take more time, so they probably need to be updated weekly – either at least once or maybe a few times a week. So find that 30 minutes to a couple of hours each week that you can update these. Set aside this time as almost sacred – you will do something no matter what the deadline crunch is (even if it is a short “Auuhhhh – deadline!” update).

I also need to point out that consistently also applies to your actual content – make sure that it is interesting and applicable to your target audience.Your online history students don’t want to read about your newest toothpaste adventures in your micro-blog.

Coming up next: Community

The Three C’s of Social Networking in Education

Here is a typical scenario in education when an instructor or administrative person decides to explore some online social networking tool. Let’s take micro-blogging for an example. You sign up for Twitter, learn to use it, and then Tweet away for a few days or even weeks. They you get busy and disappear for about the same amount of time – a couple of days or weeks (or months). Then you magically appear online again, apologizing profusely for your absence and Tweeting away… but for a shorter period of time than your first episode of activity. Then life creeps back in and you disappear again for a while. You come back to Twitter when life settles down, take a good hard look at it, and decide to give up. “No one was commenting on anything I read” or “no one seemed to respond to me or post on my wall or whatever” is your typical response, depending on the tool.

Sound familiar? I was pretty much describing my experience with several programs. The problem here is that we are applying an older educational paradigm to a new educational tool. With the old “sit and soak” educational method, your audience was still going to be there when you came back to that cool idea because, well, they had to be. You can start a cool new idea in class, then put it aside for a few weeks to get the “real” content in, and then come back to the new stuff when you get time. In the traditional educational setting, many things can be put off so that we can focus on “the basics.” Your audience – your students – will still care about their test grade even if you got to busy for a while to get it graded.

Online social networking is different. You have to look at it like building a successful television program. You have to make choices that will give people a reason to tune in… and sometimes, you may have to make a sacrifice to get that done. The sacrifice I am talking about here is not as painful as you would think. I am just talking about making some changes in mindset to get social networking happening in your educational setting.

Over the next three blog posts, I will take a look at the three C’s of online networking in education:

  • Consistency
  • Community
  • Context

Stay tuned!