In part one of this blog post I started looking at some ways that “Ai Cheerleaders” (as I refer to them) respond to “Ai Questioners” (some would say “anti-Ai” or even terms meant to be derogatory like “activists”). I need to apologize to those that fall into the middle of the two camps – I know that there are many people that don’t accept all of the Ai hype but also think there can be good uses of Ai. So there are more than the two camps that I pointed out – my mistake. There really is a spectrum with total embrace of Ai on one side and totally rejection of Ai on the other, with most of us falling somewhere between the two extremes. But there does seem to be a large cluster of people on the “Ai positive” side of the spectrum where one would place the “Cheerleader” label, and another large cluster or people on the “Ai negative” side where one would place the “Questioner” label. I got in a hurry and just decided to look at the spectrum as if there was a hard line between the positive and negative sides, but I know there are many in the middle that feel they are neither positive nor negative.

However, the two sides I focused on do exist, and one of them (Cheerleaders) drives a lot of the narrative. The “Ai Cheerleader” side seems to be having the most influence on policy these days – up to the national level in the United States. It really should give some people pause when they realize that they are in agreement with Trump, Musk, and other people… and not in a “broken clock is right twice a day” kind of way. Agreeing with people that are wrong about everything means you are, well…

The frustrating thing is that the data on Ai harms and problems, as well as concerns of the real people being forced to use Ai every day, usually lines up with the Ai Questioning side. Not always, and not perfectly – but more often than not. So you have to wonder if the Ai Cheerleader side pays good attention to the Ai Questioning side, or even the Ai Neutral or Undecided side. This part 2 will dive into these concerns more broadly.

Watching “both sides” of an issue (or “all sides”) can definitely give one a full-ranging sense of the differing viewpoints surrounding controversial issues. Generally what one comes away with when doing this is that these issues contain a lot of complexity. However, that doesn’t mean that both sides recognize this complexity. For the issue of Ai, this complexity is often the source of the concerns for the Ai Questioning side. I also think this is where a good deal of the criticism of the Ai Questioners by Ai Cheerleaders misses the point. Or even mischaracterizes the Ai Questioners altogether.

So basically I want to go through several posts by various Ai Cheerleaders and discuss the concerning ways that they frame the Ai Questioning / Skeptical / Activist side:


There are many Ai Cheerleaders that echo some sentiments like Donald Clark stated recently:

“Once again I’d emphasise that you really do have to ‘try it to get it’. An interesting paper just published showed that much of the scepticism on GenAi comes from those who have not tried it. Lesson – for any real critical thinking or analysis, some use is necessary.”

What paper? There is no link. What is getting labeled as skepticism? Are the questioners of Ai also the skeptics? Every time I speak to someone that it is skeptical of Ai, it is after they have used it. I was just on a phone call with a friend last night that was making fun of how bad an Ai program she used that day was. Most of the skepticism I read in articles comes from people that are using it.

For example, if you read Audrey Watters, it is obvious she knows Ai and even mentions when she tries it out. I mean, she has spent decades studying Ai. And she is a skeptic:

“But Ai – a large-language model or predictive algorithm or otherwise – is built on a corpus that is, quite literally, bound to the past. Education’s Ai has been trained on outmoded curriculum, exclusionary practices, and racist data; it is trained on YouTube videos and YouTube comments and Wikipedia entries; it is trained (mostly) on the English-language Internet – trained on a very small slice of knowledge and culture because not all knowledge and culture have been recorded, let alone digitized; and yet simultaneously trained on a disproportionately large slice of discrimination and violence, because that has been the experiences of Black students, poor students, students with disabilities, non-English-speaking students, undocumented students, and queer, nonbinary, and trans students.”

Did the paper that Clark mentions take into account skeptics like Watters? Or did it give the same weight to the opinion of random people who have never touched Ai (and would naturally be skeptical) as it did to those that have studied it for decades? Who knows. But there is a big difference in noting the general skepticism that always proceeds new technology (or new anything) and noting how much real skeptics know about what they question.

Also, the idea that “any real” critical thinking requires use is contrary to what we know about critical thinking.

To be clear about my concerns here:

  • Referring to a paper without linking to it or even citing it is concerning at best.
  • The implication that most skeptics haven’t tried Ai is inaccurate.
  • Implying that most criticism doesn’t come from real critical thinking is concerning.

Digging into the criticism of Ai Questioners is always hard because of there are also all of these constant inappropriate digs at questioners’ intelligence. For instance, Stephen Downes said:

“But it isn’t Ai that’s the problem, is it?…. The product isn’t the problem, the companies that control the product are. Educated people should be able to see the difference.”

This was after referring to Watters and Marc Watkins, two people who know this difference well and who mention the companies that control Ai all the time. In fact, I am having a hard time thinking of any critic that doesn’t note the difference. Most people questioning Ai are criticizing the companies that control it AND the product itself. It’s not a simple either/or. How do you separate the people that control Ai from what Ai does? Not very cleanly. But Ai has problems all on its own: very little ability to detect bad text / false results / biased or hateful responses, resource decimation, and so on.

To be clear about my concerns here:

  • Claiming there is a clean separation between the Ai products and the companies that control Ai products is not realistic.
  • Taking swipes at “educated people,” implying that people who disagree might not be well-educated on this topic, just isn’t helpful for the conversation.

Oh but wait, we are told that Ai is improving rapidly and consuming less recourses, so these problems are gone or disappearing, right? Except, when you dig into the actual proof… not so much. This claim of “consuming less resources” was made based on five charts. The first chart claims to show how “the cost of intelligence is plummeting,” but it is a chart with straight lines and some suspicious assumptions on the x-axis. I have never seen a resource consumption chart (for something like energy) that is a straight line – they always have bumps and dips. Flattening out data like this means either it is all predictive and not based on real world numbers, or you are trying to hide a trend that the bumpy line would show. However, taking the chart at face value, while it does show that “achieving GPT‑4–level performance now costs nearly 1,000 times less,” the point is never made that this “should be a relief to those with genuine concerns about the environment.” It is about saving CEOs money: “This significant drop in costs will enable companies to integrate Ai into the free tiers of their products, potentially unlocking Ai for over a billion new users.” Yeah, simple math would point out that dropping costs by 1,000 times just to add 1,000,000,000 new users means you are still using 1,000,000 times more resources. Yes, I know that would make the same math mistake that the chart itself does, but even using correct math would show these decreases in cost are just there to empower greater resource deprivation.

Oh, and where is the chart that is saying “Ai capability is improving rapidly”? Is it the chart that basically says “it is okay for Ai adoption to take time”? Is it the chart that shows consulting firms are helping with Ai adoption? Or is it the one that shows there are more parts to Ai that need to work than just the language model? Perhaps it is the really problematic one that claims “any task whose outcome can be evaluated can be learned through reinforcement learning”?

(No, this claim about reinforced learning is not true – there are many forms of evaluation that are complex and take much more than reinforcement learning. This chart is based on math courses, and many, many topics are much difference than math. So you can’t say “ANY task.” And of course we know that if learners repeat something over and over again it will stick in some way. But these learners could also end up hating learning and whatever topic you are bludgeoning them with. Seriously people – talk to an instructional designer before setting up these studies!)

To be clear about my concerns here:

  • There isn’t a chart that claims Ai is improving rapidly.
  • The chart that shows costs of Ai plummeting is suspect in different ways.
  • Showing a decrease in consumption is not a relief to those with environmental concerns, as the chart in question is used to justify an even larger increase in usage – not saving the environment. Plus, hello: look at how capitalism works.

Anyways, back to those unnecessary digs at intelligence. This one takes some set-up: Marc Watkins made the point that

“It will take years of trial and error to integrate Ai effectively in our disciplines. That’s assuming the technology will pause for a time. It won’t. Which leaves us in a constant state of trying to adapt. So, why are we investing millions in greater access to tools no one has the bandwidth or resources to learn or integrate?”

Watkins’ point was also proven by one of the five charts in the last example, so that sounds like an accurate assessment… right? Well, Stephen Downes strongly implies that this is “less” “smart thinking” and then responds:

“The assumption is that we (the instructors, the institution) must fully master the tool before it is useful to learners. But of course, that’s not true at all.”

However, that assumption is not in Watkins’ writing, because there is a difference between effectiveness and mastery. For example, I can learn how to effectively cook without mastering cooking. Most grading scales that use the term “mastery” have several levels (Does Not Meet Standards, Meet Standards, Masters Standards, etc). I can think of probably thousands of ways that effective is different than mastery. Watkins is making the point that the time it takes to learn how to use Ai effectively is too long. Sure, instructors are using Ai in courses, but many students and teachers are trying to point out it is not always very effective. And as an instructional designer, I can think of thousands of examples of instructors using technology when they really shouldn’t have. Just because they are using something, that doesn’t make said usage effective.

To be clear about my concerns here:

  • Exchanging words like “mastery” for “effective” distorts the original questioner’s point.
  • There is a very well established and known history of instructors using technology in courses, and this is obviously what Watkins is referring to.
  • Taking swipes at how “smart” thinking is or is not just because someone disagrees with you just isn’t helpful for the conversation.

Then there is the implication that skeptics are not asking the right question. When Audrey Watters elsewhere said:

“We cannot outsource thinking and compassion to a hierarchy-generating machine and expect the world to be anything other than automated emptiness and exploitation”

Stephen Downes replied:

“But that’s a different question from the one asking whether we need human teachers to teach. Now I’m not endorsing the idea “that automation will make learning better, faster, cheaper, more scalable, more ‘personalized.'” What I think technology does is to enable students to manage their own learning for themselves, so that they can be thinking and compassionate learners, and not mere automatons following a teacher’s instructions.”

Now, I can’t find where Watters was asking a question, or claimed it was the only question to ask, or that it was the same as asking whether we need human teachers. Not to mention that different questions can still have overlapping answers. So I’m confused by Downes’ response to her point. But when Downes says what “technology does is to enable students to manage their own learning for themselves, so that they can be thinking and compassionate learners, and not mere automatons following a teacher’s instructions”… he actually is claiming that technology can make learning “better” and “more ‘personalized'” (aka the opposite of automatons). He may not claim that technology is automation, but that is the goal of so many Ai programs. We also know that technology can sometimes help learners that so choose to use it that way to become more “thinking and compassionate learners” (aka “better” learners), but its the learner that does this not the technology (and sometimes in spite of what the technology forces on them). However… many learners do not get that from technology. Research shows this again and again – in fact, my own research into moving students into self-determined learning often showed that many learners actually wanted to follow the teacher’s instructions rather than choose for themselves (even if in other instances they do want to do the thinking). It’s complicated, but I rarely see technology itself making the change in the learner. Believe me, I tried to create some that did.

To be clear about my concerns here:

  • We shouldn’t be claiming someone is asking a question when they aren’t asking a question, and besides that there is room for many questions in this discussion.
  • Claiming one doesn’t think technology will make learning better or more personalized, and then turning around and saying that you believe technology can help make learning better and more personalized.

There are also concerning ways of looking at education expressed by Ai Cheerleaders. For example, Stephen Downes had this to say about knowledge:

“The knowledge is pretty much irrelevant. Not because we don’t need it, but there will always be knowledge, the knowledge always changes, and if we need to, we can always look it up.”

This is in response to a blog post by Vickie Davis that says we need a “fire that sparks the joy of learning.” My experience as a public school teacher was that most children like my son love learning – but I have to spend a lot of time pointing out when he learned something that is misinformation, when he learned an opinion as a fact, or even how to apply what he learned in real life. These are things you can rarely just look up without running into vastly opposing opinions. The idea that you can “always look it up” is problematic in today’s misinformation reality. One could respond to Downes that learning is pretty much irrelevant, because there will always be learning, it can always change, and if they need to, people can always do it on their own anyways.

We need knowledge to tell when something that we learned is misinformation. We need knowledge to know what to do with what we learned when it’s all correct but requires different uses in different contexts. Often knowledge requires knowledge of context. But even saying that would be problematic, because that all circles back to learning. We need to start realizing that knowledge, learning, application, discernment, etc are all complicated interrelated aspects that can’t be separated out and therefore shouldn’t be treated with such black and white absolutist thinking.

To be clear about my concerns here:

  • Knowledge is more complicated than saying there “will always be knowledge, the knowledge always changes, and if we need to, we can always look it up.”
  • Context of knowledge is important to knowing what to learn about said knowledge.

Anyways, while you can argue over technical details about whether Ai is destroying education or not – does any of that matter when the people in charge of Ai are working with the people that are dismantling public schools and public libraries to replace both with Ai? And they are starting to export all of this outside the United States? When many children will only get access to the Ai replacement for public schools and libraries, does it really matter if education still exists for the elite? When you find yourself promoting Ai on the same side with Trump and Musk, shouldn’t it cause you major concerns?

Because yes, while I know many believe thing like “the promise of Ai is that everybody will be able to understand other languages” and that people working with Ai will all be “well-educated high-paid professionals,” the people currently in charge of Ai companies have proven time and time again that they will charge for their products eventually, and that they will not pay people very well to work with it. There is no Ai utopia lining up in for the masses in the current MAGA era.

Of course, there are those that say that it feels “like parts of higher education face a reckoning that can’t be ignored. We need to communicate value (social and economic) to our learners and to society.” But is that really the problem? Institutions spend untold billions on advertising, recruitment, outreach, etc, etc, etc. This kind of shows that no matter how much power an institution has, if another aspect of society holds more power, and half or more of that group hates said institution and is actively working to dismantle it… no amount of value communication will overcome that power imbalance. Of course, higher ed is doing many things wrong, but I’m not sure communication of value is one of them.

I could continue citing problems with posts and articles about the Ai Questioners and how so many get us wrong. Critics of the Ai Questioning side need to do a better job of really reading what the Questioners are saying, and then need to respond without stooping to unnecessary attacks against intelligence. It would help to stop making claims about Ai that are not backed up by the papers and studies one is quoting. In part 3 (if I can find the time), I am going to look at a specific comment left on one of my posts. I think the commenter thought they would show me how good Ai is, but critique of my post that Ai came up with is so bad that it would be hilarious if it wasn’t meant in all seriousness.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Your post must include a link to this post.

How does this work?
Write a response on your own website and include a link to this post. Then submit your response’s URL here. Your response may appear here after moderation. To update or remove it, edit or delete your original post and submit the same URL again. Learn more about Webmentions.